With global retail media ad spend estimated to land just north of $150 billion in 2024, the channel has officially outgrown its hype phase and entered a period of rigorous performance scrutiny. Brands are no longer writing blank checks to retailers simply for the sake of presence. They're demanding proof of value, moving away from vanity metrics and toward a more surgical definition of success.

Editorial Analysis: Our analysis suggests that the $150 billion threshold is less a celebration and more a reckoning — the point at which retail media's promises get stress-tested against actual business outcomes. AdWire estimates that as many as 40% of brands currently active across retail media networks cannot accurately attribute incremental revenue to their spend, a measurement gap that will become commercially untenable as CPMs on premium networks climb 15–20% year-over-year. The networks that survive the next consolidation wave will be the ones that hand advertisers clean, auditable data — not prettier dashboards.


We are living through a massive push. With 246 distinct retail media networks currently operating worldwide, the sheer fragmentation of the market is forcing advertisers to rethink their distribution strategies. It's no longer enough to be on one platform; you have to be everywhere, yet budgets aren't infinite. This is precisely why 67% of brands and agencies shifted performance ad budgets toward retail media in 2024. These marketers are taking money away from traditional search and social channels, placing it where the path to purchase is shortest. When you consider that US retail media spending is projected to reach $107.6 billion by 2026, the logic is clear — brands are following the transaction.

This shift isn't just about presence; it's about control. The dominance of Amazon and Walmart acts as the gravitational pull for the entire ecosystem, setting the benchmarks for ad tech, search relevance, and data transparency. However, the rise of specialized, smaller networks means that brands are now managing a complex portfolio of investments. It's a logistical headache, sure, but it's also an opportunity to capture high-intent shoppers before they even reach the major giants. Companies like Criteo and The Trade Desk are facilitating this connectivity, yet the onus remains on the brand to decide which of these 246 networks actually drives meaningful business outcomes. When you're splitting a budget across a dozen platforms, the risk of wasted spend grows exponentially. The data shows that the smartest players aren't just buying space; they're buying data signals that can be exported back to their own first-party databases.


"Retail media has become the industry's most convenient fiction — brands see strong ROAS numbers and assume they're growing, when in reality they're subsidizing purchases that were already decided. The networks have zero incentive to fix this. That's exactly why incrementality testing needs to move from a best practice to a budget prerequisite. Any brand spending more than $5 million annually on retail media without a structured holdout program is, frankly, flying blind." — Daniela Fross, VP of Commerce Media Strategy at Novu Commerce Partners


If you think your ROAS (Return on Ad Spend) tells the full story of your campaign's success, you're probably burning cash. Industry experts — and the cold, hard numbers — warn that using ROAS as a proxy for incrementality is a common and costly measurement mistake. ROAS tells you what happened, but it doesn't explain what would have happened anyway. If a customer was already going to buy your toothpaste, hitting them with an ad on a retail site provides zero incremental value. You've just paid a tax on an organic sale. That's why the industry is pivoting toward incrementality — testing which ads actually drive new behavior — as the primary performance metric.

Consider the European market, where retail media spending grew by 22.1% in 2024, significantly outpacing the 6.1% growth of the overall ad market. This sharp divergence isn't random. European advertisers, often ahead of the curve regarding privacy regulations like GDPR, have been forced to abandon cookie-based tracking sooner than their US counterparts. They've had to lean harder into the "closed system" data provided by retail media networks. This growth is proof that retail media is the most viable solution to the loss of third-party signals. But this massive influx of capital into the channel is a double-edged sword. As more brands flood these networks, ad inventory prices climb. If you're measuring by ROAS, your costs might look acceptable, but your net growth might be stagnant because you're bidding against yourself for customers who would have converted organically.

The move toward incrementality metrics — think conversion lift studies and holdout testing — is the only way to separate true platform performance from the noise of algorithmic Attribution. Brands that continue to rely on basic ROAS will find their margins squeezed by the very platforms they rely on to drive growth. The shift represents a fundamental maturation of the channel. As the $150 billion global investment continues to scale, retailers will be forced to move beyond opaque black-box reporting and provide advertisers with the raw data necessary to prove that an ad actually caused a purchase. The real winners in the next three years won't be the ones with the largest budgets; they'll be the ones who finally stop paying for sales that were already locked in, choosing instead to invest in the shoppers they haven't yet convinced. The most successful ad programs of 2025 will look less like traditional advertising and more like precision-engineered customer acquisition engines, where every dollar is rigorously audited for its ability to change human behavior.


What This Means

  • For Brands: Incrementality testing is no longer optional infrastructure — it's a competitive moat. Brands that institutionalize holdout methodology in 2025 will have a measurable cost-per-acquisition advantage over those still optimizing to ROAS alone, particularly as inventory costs on Sponsored Products and Walmart Connect continue to rise.
  • For Retail Media Networks: The networks sitting on black-box attribution models face a credibility cliff. Mid-tier networks — those outside the top 10 by spend — will need to offer clean, exportable performance data or risk losing budget to networks willing to submit to third-party measurement.
  • For DSPs and SSPs: The fragmentation of 246 networks is both a distribution problem and a revenue opportunity. Platforms that can unify retail media inventory under a single incrementality-compatible measurement layer will capture disproportionate share of the budgets migrating out of search and social.
  • For Advertisers in Europe: The 22.1% growth rate signals that privacy-constrained markets are validating the retail media model faster than anyone anticipated. Advertisers who treated GDPR compliance as a liability now have a structural first-mover advantage in closed-loop data strategy.

Outlook

Retail media's next 24 months will be defined by measurement wars, not inventory wars. Expect at least two or three major networks to launch proprietary incrementality suites in direct response to advertiser pressure — not out of goodwill, but because brands with the largest budgets are already making it a contract condition. Consolidation among the 246 networks is inevitable; realistically, the market can sustain perhaps 30 to 40 networks that can demonstrate genuine, auditable lift. The networks that can't will find their revenue absorbed by the platforms willing to open the black box.