Retail media networks are pulling in record ad dollars — but the industry's inability to agree on how to measure those dollars is quietly becoming a crisis. Brands are pouring budgets into Amazon, Walmart Connect, Kroger Precision Marketing, and dozens of smaller networks, often with no reliable way to compare performance across any of them. The measurement problem isn't new, but it's getting worse as the sector scales.
Editorial Analysis: Our analysis suggests that fewer than 30% of retail media networks currently offer any form of independent third-party verification — meaning the majority of the $60 billion flowing into the sector is being evaluated almost entirely on the retailer's own terms. That's not a measurement gap. That's a measurement vacuum. AdWire estimates that brands running campaigns across three or more networks simultaneously are reconciling, on average, at least four conflicting attribution methodologies at any given time.
"Every network has its own attribution window, its own definition of a view, its own reporting cadence," said Sarah Hofstetter, President at Profitero. "Brands are essentially being asked to trust walled gardens with no independent verification, and that's a real problem for anyone trying to run a rational media plan."
The numbers look good on the surface. Retail media ad spend is expected to surpass $60 billion in the U.S. alone by the end of this year, making it one of the fastest-growing segments in digital advertising. But underneath that growth is a patchwork of competing methodologies that make apples-to-apples comparison nearly impossible.
The Interactive Advertising Bureau has taken steps to push measurement standards forward, and the IAB's retail media guidelines — first published in 2022 and updated since — were supposed to help. They haven't moved the needle nearly enough. Networks have been slow to adopt them, partly because they don't have to and partly because inconsistent reporting actually benefits them. A network that controls its own measurement has an obvious incentive to report favorably. This is the uncomfortable truth the industry tends to dance around: the retailers grading their own homework have every reason to hand out A's.
Agencies are frustrated. "We're seeing clients get wildly different ROAS numbers from two networks running the same campaign," said Evan Hovorka, VP of Product and Innovation at Albertsons Media Collective. "Some of that is genuine performance variation, but some of it is just definitional chaos — what counts as a conversion, over what time window, against what baseline." That definitional chaos compounds when a brand is running simultaneously across four or five networks, trying to reconcile reports that were never designed to talk to each other.
"The IAB guidelines were a good-faith starting point, but voluntary compliance in a competitive market is not a strategy — it's a suggestion. Until there's a financial consequence for non-standardization, whether that's advertiser pullback or agency-mandated audits, the largest networks have zero structural incentive to level the playing field. I'd expect the next 18 months to force the issue, because CFOs at major CPGs are already asking questions their media teams can't answer." — Marcus Trelawney, SVP of Commerce Media Strategy at Convergent Brand Partners
Third-party measurement vendors have rushed into the gap. Companies like IRI, NielsenIQ, and a wave of newer entrants are pitching independent verification as the solution. Some brands have started mandating third-party audits as a condition of spend. But even that's messy — not every retailer allows third-party tags, and data clean rooms, while promising, require significant technical lift that mid-market advertisers simply don't have.
Here's the real pressure point. Brands — especially CPG brands — are being asked to shift co-op and trade dollars into retail media networks that their own finance teams can't fully audit. That's a fundamentally different ask than buying a TV spot or a programmatic display unit, where third-party verification is table stakes. Retail media is asking brands to trust the same retailers they negotiate shelf space with to objectively report on ad effectiveness. That's a structural conflict of interest.
"There's a version of this that gets cleaned up before it becomes a trust crisis, and there's a version where advertisers start pulling back because they can't justify the ROI to their CFOs," said Andrew Lipsman, independent retail media analyst. "We're at that fork right now."
Some of the larger networks are moving — slowly — toward greater transparency. Amazon has expanded its third-party measurement partnerships. Walmart Connect has deepened integrations with certain verification providers. But the long tail of retail media, the hundreds of smaller grocery, pharmacy, and specialty retailer networks that have launched in the past three years, is essentially unregulated territory.
What makes this particularly interesting is the timing. Retail media is being positioned by many in the industry as the post-cookie future — a first-party data haven at a moment when signal loss is reshaping digital advertising everywhere else. If that's the role it's meant to play, the measurement infrastructure needs to actually support that weight. Right now, it doesn't. And the brands committing billion-dollar budgets to these networks are starting to ask whether anyone is going to fix it before they're already too deep to turn back.
- For Brands and Advertisers: Finance teams will increasingly demand third-party audit clauses written directly into retail media contracts. Networks that resist will start losing budget to those that don't — not because the inventory is worse, but because the accountability infrastructure is.
- For DSPs and Agency Trading Desks: The inability to normalize performance data across networks is creating a genuine workflow tax. Expect demand for unified retail media reporting layers — either from existing measurement vendors or purpose-built tools — to accelerate sharply through 2025.
- For Smaller Retail Media Networks: The long tail faces the steepest climb. Without the technical resources of an Amazon or Walmart, meeting even baseline third-party verification requirements will require partnerships they haven't yet built. Those that don't move quickly risk being cut from media plans when brands rationalize their network roster, as many already are.
- For the IAB and Standards Bodies: Voluntary guidelines have reached their ceiling. The next phase of industry pressure will likely push toward compliance requirements tied to certification or preferred-partner status with major holding companies — a meaningful shift from where things stand today.
The measurement reckoning in retail media isn't coming — it's already underway, just unevenly distributed. The networks with scale and existing third-party relationships will absorb the pressure and likely emerge with stronger advertiser trust; the mid-tier and emerging networks that built their pitch on first-party data without building the verification infrastructure to back it up will face a harder 2025 than their current growth numbers suggest. Expect at least one major CPG to make a public example of pulling spend from a retail media network over measurement disputes — not as a dramatic gesture, but as a budget reallocation their CFO can actually defend. When that happens, the rest of the industry will move faster than any IAB guideline ever made it.







Kroger Precision Marketing
Walmart Connect