AdWire: Retail media spending hit $62 billion in 2025, yet you're focused on the 99% of the iceberg that's still underwater: the physical store. Having sat through three separate vendor pitches this month where "in-store digitization" was reduced to a glorified PowerPoint about QR codes on shelves, I'm skeptical. Why should buyers believe this is anything more than another expensive line item for retailers to recoup their CapEx?

Sarah: I appreciate the skepticism, Sarah, because you're right- most of what's been pitched as "in-store retail media" is just digital wallpaper. But look at the math: we have this massive $62 billion digital market, yet only 0.7% of ad spend touches the physical shelf, where the VAST majority of food and beverage sales actually happen. We're moving past the "QR code on a shelf talker" phase. The shift now is toward infrastructure- smart shelving, IoT-enabled displays, and integrated point-of-sale data that talks back to the ad server. It isn't about vanity; it's about capturing the 80% of purchase decisions made in the aisle.

AdWire Analysis: Our analysis suggests that the 0.7% figure Jenkins cites isn't a gap — it's a structural failure that the industry has been content to ignore because online retail media is easier to measure and faster to monetize. AdWire estimates that closing even a fraction of that gap, say to 5% of total retail media spend directed at in-store digital inventory, would unlock roughly $3 billion in net-new ad revenue that currently has no addressable home. The brands are willing. The infrastructure isn't there yet.

AdWire: The biggest headache for my readers isn't the hardware; it's the reporting vacuum. Sixty-one percent of buyers cite measurement fragmentation as their primary hurdle. If you're bridging the gap between a display in a store in Ohio and a digital dashboard in a New York media agency, how do you stop the data from becoming a messy, non-comparable nightmare?

Sarah: You stop trying to force in-store metrics to look exactly like a Click-Through Rate. The trap most platforms fall into is trying to map every impulse buy to an exact ad impression, which is technically shaky and practically impossible. We're leaning into closed-loop measurement that prioritizes incremental sales lift and basket analysis over vanity clicks. By syncing store-level POS data directly with the campaign management platform, we can prove the lift happened in the specific store where the ad ran. It's about building a common currency for performance that reconciles digital impressions with physical register receipts.

"The measurement conversation in retail media is broken because everyone defaults to digital proxies — Viewability, impressions, CPMs — for a channel that is fundamentally about physical conversion. Until the industry agrees on a standardized sales-lift methodology tied directly to store-level POS data, we're just billing brands for screens they can't prove moved product." — Marcus Delvey, VP of Commerce Media Strategy at Archway Partners

AdWire: The market is clearly consolidating. We're seeing smaller, boutique retail media networks struggling to scale, while the giants vacuum up the ad dollars. Are you worried that by pushing this tech-heavy, infrastructure-first model, you're pricing out the smaller players and turning retail media into a closed club for the top ten global retailers?

Sarah: I actually disagree with the premise that consolidation is a negative force here. The fragmentation we currently have is exactly what's scaring off the big-budget brand advertisers who want scale without managing fifty different dashboard logins. Smaller networks don't necessarily lose because they can't afford the hardware; they lose because they can't provide the ease of access that a Walmart or a Kroger can. We need fewer, stronger networks that provide a standardized API for buyers. If a mid-tier retailer wants to compete, they shouldn't build a proprietary ad-stack from scratch- they should plug into a platform that handles the complexity for them.

AdWire: Let's talk about the "AI in the aisle" narrative. It's become a catch-all term for anything involving an algorithm, but how is it actually changing the day-to-day for a campaign manager?

Sarah: It's moving us from manual optimization to real-time execution. In the past, you'd run a two-week in-store creative test, pull the data, and realize by the time you made changes, the campaign was already over. With AI-driven creative automation, we're now seeing platforms that can swap assets on digital endcaps based on inventory levels or even time-of-day traffic patterns. If the data shows a spike in demand for soda on a Friday afternoon, the creative shifts to highlight that specific SKU without a human needing to manually upload a new file. It's automated agility, not just "AI" as a buzzword.

AdWire: If we revisit this conversation in two years, what does the "retail media store" look like? Is it a high-tech environment where the screen knows my name, or is it a smarter version of the status quo?

Sarah: It's definitely not "Minority Report" style personalized tracking, because the privacy-first world we live in won't support it. Instead, you'll see the store become a performance channel that functions with the same automated rigor as a programmatic display campaign. You'll be able to buy an ad that triggers on a digital display in a specific store because the system knows your brand is overstocked in that specific zip code. It's about operational efficiency meeting customer intent, not stalking shoppers through the aisles. The winners will be the ones who turn the physical environment into a predictable, measurable growth engine.

What This Means

  • For Brands and Advertisers: The case for shifting a meaningful portion of trade spend — historically managed offline and opaque — into measurable in-store digital inventory is strengthening fast. CPG brands in particular should be stress-testing their agency agreements to ensure in-store retail media is a line item, not an afterthought.
  • For DSPs: Demand-side platforms that haven't built or acquired in-store inventory connectors are already behind. The ability to execute a single campaign across programmatic display and a physical endcap in the same interface is no longer a differentiator — it's becoming table stakes.
  • For Smaller Retail Media Networks: Jenkins is right that proprietary stack-building is a dead end for mid-tier players. The smarter path is API-first partnerships with platform aggregators, even if that means surrendering some margin to avoid irrelevance entirely.
  • For SSPs: The supply-side opportunity here is significant but underbuilt. Physical retail inventory — digital screens, endcaps, entrance displays — needs the same programmatic pipes that online publishers built over the last decade. Whoever standardizes that supply layer first has a defensible position.

Outlook

In-store retail media will not displace digital overnight, but the next 18 months will likely produce the industry's first credible, widely adopted measurement standard for physical-to-register Attribution — probably driven by pressure from large CPG advertisers tired of paying for reach they can't reconcile. The retailers that move now to wire their stores for real-time data feedback will command meaningfully higher CPMs than those still selling static placements by 2027. Those who wait for the standard to emerge before investing in infrastructure will find themselves locked out of premium budgets that have already committed elsewhere.