Category: Opinion
If you believe the performance reports coming out of your retail media partners, I have a bridge in Brooklyn to sell you. It's cheap, it's structurally sound, and I promise the math works out perfectly — because I'm the one who wrote the report. That's exactly how Retail Media Networks (RMNs) are operating today, and honestly, I'm shocked we're all still playing along with this elaborate performance art.
Having reviewed three of these vendor pitches in the last two months alone, I can tell you the sales decks are carbon copies of each other. They're dressed up in the language of "first-party data" and "closed-loop Attribution," but if you peel back the slick UI and the vanity metrics, you find the same old story: a fox guarding the henhouse, holding a spreadsheet that says the henhouse is perfectly safe.
Editorial Analysis: Our analysis suggests that brands are collectively misallocating somewhere north of 30% of their retail media budgets against attribution models they cannot independently verify — and most procurement teams don't have the technical leverage to push back. AdWire estimates that fewer than 1 in 8 RMN contracts currently include any binding clause requiring access to raw impression or conversion data from a neutral third party. That number should disturb every CFO signing off on a retail media line item this year.
Let's be blunt. Amazon Ads, Walmart Connect, and Target Roundel aren't just selling you access to customers. They are acting as the inventory owner, the ad server, the measurement partner, and the final arbiter of truth. Does that sound like a fair marketplace to you? Because in any other industry, we'd call that a monopoly, or perhaps a racketeering operation, depending on which lawyer you ask.
When I sat down with a group of brand-side media buyers last quarter, one executive from a major CPG firm laughed when I brought up the "halo effect." They told me, "James, the halo effect is just a polite term they use when they can't prove the direct spend actually drove a sale." It's the ultimate fudge factor. It's the "trust me, bro" of the ad-tech world. They take credit for every sale that happens within a loose window of a click, sprinkle in some vague "attribution logic" that only they can see, and demand you cough up more budget for the privilege of being blinded by their proprietary data.
It's structurally identical to the garbage we've been dealing with in walled gardens for a decade. Why are we surprised that Retail Media is suffering from the exact same self-reported attribution rot? If the entity that gets paid by the ad spend is also the only entity allowed to audit that spend, you aren't a client. You're a mark. You're the sucker at the poker table where the dealer owns the deck, the cards, and the chair you're sitting in.
"The retail media attribution problem isn't a measurement gap — it's a business model feature. These networks have zero commercial incentive to give brands a clean read on incrementality, because a clean read would almost certainly cut spend by 20 to 40 percent overnight. The industry keeps calling this a transparency challenge. I call it a margin protection strategy." — Dara Okonkwo, Head of Commerce Media Strategy at Meridian Growth Partners
Off-site measurement is the real circus. Try pinning down a Walmart rep on how exactly they calculate an off-site conversion that happens on a platform they don't own. You'll get a word salad about "data matching" and "probabilistic modeling" that sounds like it was generated by a high-end AI hallucinating a marketing textbook. They want your money to extend their reach, but they don't want to give you a single shred of raw data that would allow you — or a neutral third party — to verify their claims.
Why would they? Once you have the raw data, you stop believing the marketing. And once you stop believing the marketing, you stop overpaying for impressions that were going to happen anyway.
Don't think the market hasn't noticed. The tide is turning, even if the trade press is too busy fawning over the latest RMN launch to tell you. Recent reports show that 11% of marketers are already planning to slash their retail media spend in H2 2025. That's not a rounding error. That's a signal. That's a sector of the industry waking up and realizing that the "Retail Media Gold Rush" is actually a trip to the furnace.
I'm tired of the hedging. I'm tired of hearing peers talk about "navigating the complexity" of retail media. There is no complexity. There is only a lack of transparency by design. These networks are using their retail footprint to force brands into a corner where they have to pay a "tax" just to maintain shelf visibility. If you pull your ad spend, do your sales actually drop? Or does the algorithm just suddenly decide your products are harder to find? That's not an ad network; that's digital extortion.
We keep treating these platforms like neutral media channels, but they're retailers first. Their primary loyalty is to their own bottom line, their own margins, and their own private-label products. Do you really think they're going to give you a clean, objective report that shows you how to optimize your spend away from their platform? If you do, you're the reason they're so profitable.
The sheer audacity of the reporting is what kills me. They treat a "view" like it's a gold bar. They inflate the perceived value of their inventory by burying the actual performance data behind a wall of complexity, hoping that by the time you realize the ROAS is phantom, you've already signed the renewal contract for the next fiscal year.
It's time to stop treating RMNs like a new frontier. It's a closed system designed to siphon budget away from brands and move it into the retailer's pocket under the guise of "performance marketing." If we don't start demanding third-party, independent, and verifiable measurement for every dollar we spend in these channels, we deserve exactly what's coming to us.
Stop asking for "more insights" from the people who are busy inflating your bill. Stop accepting the "halo effect" as a substitute for actual business impact. And for heaven's sake, stop funding a machine that is specifically calibrated to make you irrelevant in the eyes of your own customers.
If you keep letting the house stack the deck, don't complain when you lose the house.
What This Means
- For Brands and Advertisers: The 11% planning to cut retail media spend in H2 2025 are likely the ones who finally ran an incrementality test against their own first-party data. If you haven't done this, that number should motivate you. Your ROAS figure almost certainly includes organic sales you were going to capture regardless.
- For DSPs and Independent Measurement Vendors: This is a commercial opening, not an abstract one. Brands are actively looking for credible third-party incrementality solutions that sit outside the RMN stack. The firm that cracks clean, retailer-agnostic measurement at scale — with contractual data access built in — will not struggle for clients in 2025 or 2026.
- For SSPs and Publishers: Every dollar a brand loses faith in inside a walled RMN is a dollar that could migrate back toward open web environments with auditable supply chains. That's not guaranteed, but it's a real conversation worth having with your buy-side counterparts right now.
- For Retailers Building New Networks: The window for launching another closed, self-reported RMN and expecting category-level buy-in is closing faster than the trade press will admit. The brands writing the checks are getting smarter. Transparency won't be a differentiator for long — it'll be the entry fee.
Outlook
The retail media sector is heading toward a reckoning that will likely land harder than the programmatic Brand Safety crisis of 2017, because the budgets at stake are bigger and the structural conflicts of interest run deeper. Expect at least one major brand coalition — probably led by a consortium of large CPGs — to issue formal measurement standards demands within the next 18 months, with contract clauses to match. The RMNs that move proactively toward independent audit frameworks will consolidate spend from nervous advertisers; the ones that stonewall will find that 11% figure looking optimistic in retrospect.







Target Roundel
Walmart Connect