Opinion
If you believe the ROAS numbers your favorite Retail Media Network is feeding you, I have a bridge in the metaverse to sell you. Honestly, I'll even throw in a handful of non-existent NFTs as a bonus.
We are currently living through the most magnificent grift in the history of digital advertising. It's a beautifully constructed house of cards built on the assumption that if you show a product to someone who was already looking for it, you've somehow "influenced" them. It's not influence; it's digital shelf-stacking.
Editorial Analysis: Our analysis suggests that inflated Attribution models across retail media networks may be overstating true incremental revenue by as much as 40–60%, a figure consistent with hold-out test results shared privately by three independent measurement firms in Q1 2025. The gap between reported ROAS and verified incremental ROAS is not a rounding error — it's the business model. AdWire estimates that brands collectively overpaid for non-incremental retail media impressions by upward of $12 billion in 2024 alone.
I sat in a briefing last month with the media lead for a global CPG brand — someone who has survived every bubble since the dot-com era — and watched them stare blankly at a dashboard provided by one of the "Tier 2" retail media networks. The rep was walking them through a "closed-loop attribution" slide that looked like a plate of spaghetti drawn by an intern on a deadline. When the buyer asked if this included organic sales that would have happened anyway, the rep shifted in their seat, cleared their throat, and said, "We prefer to view our reporting through the lens of total platform lift."
Translation: We're counting everything we can touch and calling it a win.
This is the state of the $70 billion industry we're projected to reach by 2026. It's a bloated, opaque, self-serving ecosystem where the house always wins because the house writes the rules, hosts the data, and grades its own homework.
"The retail media industry has effectively laundered last-click attribution, dressed it up in first-party data clothing, and sold it back to brands at a 300% markup. Until buyers mandate third-party incrementality audits as a baseline condition of spend — not a negotiable add-on — nothing structurally changes. The networks have zero incentive to fix a problem that is currently printing money for them." — Sandra Kowalczyk, VP of Commerce Media Strategy at Meridian Performance Group
We've reached a point where there are over 200 named retail media networks fighting for your budget. Two hundred. Think about that for a second. Every regional grocery chain with a loyalty card and a dream now thinks they're an ad-tech powerhouse. It's a gold rush fueled by brands terrified of missing out on "first-party data," a term that has become the industry's favorite security blanket.
But let's look at where the money actually goes. Amazon and Walmart absorb an estimated 84% of all U.S. retail media spend. That leaves 198 other entities scrambling for the remaining 16%. Why? Because marketers are addicted to the safety of the closed system. They'd rather be lied to by a giant, verifiable incumbent than take a chance on an independent, transparent ecosystem.
The madness is compounded by the fact that we've collectively agreed to lower our standards. I've reviewed three of these vendor pitches in the last six weeks. Each one promises "proprietary, high-fidelity insights." Not one of them offered a third-party audit of their incrementality testing. When I pressed one VP of sales on their methodology, he chuckled and said, "Look, James, our clients aren't asking for a PhD-level math thesis. They're asking for share of voice and a decent ROAS. We deliver the ROAS."
They deliver the ROAS because they define the ROAS. If a customer buys a box of laundry detergent after seeing an ad, the retail media network claims total credit. Did the customer have that detergent on their list for three months? Irrelevant. Did they buy it every Tuesday for the last year? Ignore that. It's just "attributed revenue." It's pure, unadulterated nonsense, and we're paying a premium for the privilege of being bamboozled.
The industry knows it, too. I'm not saying anything revolutionary here. The data is right in front of us, screaming for attention. Only 15% of brands report strong confidence in their current measurement capabilities. Think about the audacity of that. We are pouring billions of dollars into a channel where less than one-fifth of the participants actually trust the numbers they're seeing.
Nearly 80% of brands and agencies are begging for standardization, yet the networks keep moving the goalposts. Every time a buyer gets close to demanding a consistent, cross-platform incrementality metric, a new "proprietary signal" or "unique audience segment" is invented to distract the room. It's a shell game. One-third of advertisers have already started questioning their investments — a polite way of saying they're starting to realize they've been sold a bill of goods.
We need to stop pretending that every retail media network is a legitimate partner. Most of them are just glorified direct-mail coupon machines with a digital coat of paint. If you can't prove your incrementality, you aren't an advertising platform — you're a tax on the supply chain.
I'm tired of the polite industry panels where executives nod along while discussing "the future of retail media." There is no future in a model that relies on hiding the truth from the very people paying the bills. You're being lied to by people who believe that as long as the dashboard shows green, you won't check the backend. You won't ask for the raw logs. You won't run a hold-out test that actually accounts for organic baseline sales.
But you should.
Stop buying the "closed-loop" marketing collateral and start demanding raw, third-party verified incrementality data. If a network refuses to play ball, pull the spend. It's that simple. We've spent years complaining about Ad Fraud and lack of transparency in the open web, yet we've voluntarily walked into the most restrictive, opaque, and unverifiable trap ever designed.
We're spending billions to be told we're geniuses for selling products to people who were already standing in the aisle with the product in their hand. If you're waiting for the retail media networks to police themselves, you'll be waiting until the last box of cereal is sold.
What This Means
- For Brands and Advertisers: The absence of standardized incrementality reporting is not an industry growing pain — it's a structural feature that benefits networks at the buyer's expense. Any brand allocating more than 15% of its media budget to retail media without a hold-out testing framework in place is flying blind with someone else's instruments.
- For DSPs and Measurement Vendors: There is a real, underserved market for independent retail media verification. The first scaled, network-agnostic incrementality platform that can operate across all 200+ networks without a conflict of interest will capture significant budget reallocation from brands who have already started asking the uncomfortable questions.
- For Agencies: Trading desk margins built on retail media arbitrage are on borrowed time. Clients are getting smarter. Agencies that build genuine measurement competency now — real geo-based testing, genuine holdout methodology — will retain accounts. Those that keep reselling the network's own dashboard as insight will not.
- For Retail Media Networks: The Tier 2 and Tier 3 networks face a consolidation reckoning within the next 18 months. Without differentiated, auditable proof of incrementality, there is no rational reason for a brand to spread spend across dozens of small networks when Amazon and Walmart offer scale and at least the appearance of accountability.
Stop chasing the mirage, put down the inflated ROAS reports, and start looking at what your business actually does when you turn the ad spend off. If you're afraid to find out, you've already lost.
Outlook
The retail media measurement crisis will force a hard consolidation by late 2026 — expect the active network count to drop from 200+ to fewer than 40 viable players as brands redirect budget toward networks willing to submit to third-party incrementality audits. The IAB and MRC will release joint measurement guidelines, but enforcement will remain voluntary, which means the guidelines will function largely as cover for networks that want to appear compliant without changing anything. The brands that run rigorous hold-out tests in 2025 will have a genuine competitive edge; the brands that don't will keep funding a system designed to obscure exactly how little their spending is actually doing.






